May 4, 2013; Las Vegas, NV, USA; Floyd Mayweather (black gloves) and Robert Guerrero (red gloves) during their WBC Welterweight title fight at the MGM Grand Garden Arena. Mayweather won unanimously. Mandatory Credit: Jayne Kamin-Oncea-USA TODAY Sports

Unanswered Prayers: Floyd Mayweather Jr. W12 Robert Guerrero


It was a fight short on drama, one that prompted a smattering of boos among the throng gathered at the MGM Grand Garden Arena in Las Vegas, Nevada. And yet, there is a compliment buried in this criticism. For in so easily dismantling Robert Guerrero over twelve one-sided rounds on Saturday night, Floyd Mayweather, Jr., displayed a fighting prowess that, even at age 36, remains remarkable. One can take issue with some of the names on—and off—his ledger and disapprove of his preference for avoiding rather than delivering damage, but the drama of a Mayweather fight is most often lost in the yet-to-be traversed expanse between his competition’s ability and his own. And that, no matter how you look at it, is high praise.

Guerrero, to his credit, looked to cross that void in the early rounds. Mayweather began the fight planted directly in front of Guerrero, where he stung with lead and counter right hands. Regardless of the success of Mayweather’s volleys—and there was little in the early going—Guerrero countered each shot with a left uppercut to the body. This triggered response, even when it missed, kept Mayweather leery of opening up. Coming off of a vindictive bullying of Andre Berto, Guerrero was expected to try and hound Mayweather in close, nullifying his speed. In fact, he did the opposite: instead of swarming, Guerrero, Gilroy, California, looked to counter Mayweather, ostensibly forcing him to take the lead. The rationale seemed sound: a stationary Mayweather forced to lead would be a more available target. The Berto fight aside, Guerrero is most comfortable countering and boxing at range, and playing to his strengths—rather than Mayweather’s weaknesses—made for some tense moments early in the fight. Reduced to throwing little more than a jab and straight right, Mayweather still carried the action early; but Guerrero was getting dangerously close with his punches. It looked as though Mayweather had a fight on his hands.

Perhaps the only quality moment in those dreary hours of “All Access” and the scripted redundancies that are the personas of Mayweather and Guerrero occurred when the fighters first met before the cameras. Mayweather stuck his nose in Guerrero’s face while repeating the phrase, “This ain’t Berto,” dismissing the notion that Guerrero’s outmuscling of the pedestrian Berto—who was coming off an injury and experimenting with techniques too advanced for him—could serve as preparation for the Mayweather riddle. Despite a slow start, Mayweather, Grand Rapids, Michigan, would punctuate his mouth with his fists.

“This ain’t Berto.”

In the fourth round Mayweather, 146, abandoned his stationary approach and went on the offensive, darting in and out of range, slamming Guerrero with blistering right hands. His 36 year-old legs had betrayed signs of erosion in recent fights, but against Guerrero, Mayweather moved with a fluidity conspicuously absent in his last fight (an unexpectedly rough tussle with shopworn junior middleweight Miguel Cotto). No longer lingering within range, Mayweather’s increased movement forced Guerrero to check his output, lest he be punished for errors of timing or distance. Alternating between straight and looping right hands to the head and body, Mayweather kept Guerrero guessing defensively—and guessing incorrectly.

“This ain’t Berto.”

A thudding right hand opened a cut over Guerrero’s left eye in the eighth, a round that saw him do little but trudge forward, suffer and bleed. Undaunted, Guerrero, 147, tried to muscle Mayweather in close, and had some success strafing his momentarily corralled opponent. But it would be wrong to say that Guerrero won these cramped exchanges. Mayweather, unlike Berto—who has all the menace of a tortoise on its back when fighting along the ropes—either clamped down on Guerrero until referee Robert Byrd intervened, or worked free with stinging combinations. Blood streaming from his eye, getting far worse than he gave, Guerrero had been put in the stocks.

Mayweather’s onslaught, however, waned significantly over the remainder of the fight (which he later attributed to an injured right hand). Guerrero paid less dearly for those remaining minutes in the ring; this mitigated abuse perhaps constituting his greatest success as the fight neared its obvious conclusion. At the final bell, Guerrero thrust his arms triumphantly in the air while his father, Ruben, revisited his role as a vexing ignoramus. But the time for rabble rousing had passed. All three judges scored the bout 117-111 for Mayweather.

Prior to his fight with Guerrero, Mayweather, 44-0 (26), said he would return in September for the second fight of his Showtime deal. That deal calls for Mayweather—who has fought six times in six years—to fight six times in thirty months. Showtime might as well have asked for female bachelors and four-sided triangles. Even if Mayweather was genuine in his September intent, the hand injury could delay his return (which, really, would just allow him to keep the schedule he’s had since 2008). Many hope that when he returns, it will be against massively popular junior middleweight Saul Alvarez, whose credibility is peaking after his win over Austin Trout. When asked about future foes, and Alvarez in particular, however, Mayweather was typically noncommittal. Whomever Mayweather chooses to fight, it’s hard to see public demand being a factor. He has long dictated the terms of his career, and is unlikely to concede such control now.

With his ties to Golden Boy Promotions, Guerrero, 31-2-1 (18), has a number of options. He could fight Victor Ortiz, Keith Thurman, or the winner of the Paulie Malignaggi-Adrien Broner fight. If he is willing to hit the buffet, he might even have a chance at a fight with Alvarez, who, in an act of gamesmanship, could look to improve on Mayweather’s performance. Yes, Guerrero, durable, determined, still has options. But watching him leave the ring, a line from Sabbath’s Theater came to mind: “If only things had been different, everything would be otherwise.” Alas, he fought an aging yet indomitable fighter, one whose talent still casts a shadow over the welterweight division. No amount of inspiration, prayer, or public support could propel him over the expanse.

“This ain’t Berto.”

Follow The Cruelest Sport on Twitter & Facebook and follow the only boxing website with its own Theme Song!


Tags: Floyd Mayweather Jr. Robert Guerrero

  • Dracule Mihawk

    he cant win in winning.. he cant beat the PACMAN

  • Michael Nelson

    Hey JT,

    Great work. Floyd’s legs were a lot livelier than I expected, and his performance harkened back to his pre-”retirement” days, all the way down to the sore hand. Spectacular moments on the way to a banal conclusion in front of a bored crowd. Some of the condescension I saw afterwards about how much I was supposed to enjoy it irked me, but as you said, the lack of drama itself is worthy of praise.

    Guerrero was flinching at every feint by the mid-rounds, and counter jabs completely handcuffed him. Once he started thinking, it was over and not all that interesting.

    • Jimmy Tobin

      Hi MN,

      “Spectacular moments on the way to a banal conclusion in front of a bored crowd.” Exactly. Perfectly said.

      I was with Andy, and he said something along the lines of, “Well, that wasn’t remotely entertaining.” And he’s right. The eighth round, when Mayweather was firing on all cylinders was a sight to behold. But that’s one round, and a round against Robert Guerrero (which isn’t entirely Floyd’s fault.)

      As good as he is, unless he’s in against Martinez, or some similar challenge, I can’t justify paying for his performances.

  • Antwonomous

    This fight forced me to re-evaluate the Cotto bout. I’d always thought that Cotto would have been no real challenge for Mayweather when both were at their peak, and the fact that it was so competitive when they fought last year convinced me that Mayweather had slowed (we know that Cotto has, too, but he turned back the clock that night). Seeing Mayweather have such an easy time with Guerrero made me realize that Cotto deserves all the credit for how Mayweather looked against him. Mayweather needed and used his legs that night after not needing them in his prior three fights, but he could only use them so much because Miguel Cotto knew how to cut off the ring, corner him, and keep him there with fierce, sustained attacks of combination punching. Guerrero didn’t know how to do that, so Mayweather was able to dance at will. Mayweather is not what he was at his apex, surely, but he remains closer to his best than the Cotto fight had us believe. That fight last May told me more about Cotto than it did Mayweather, as it turns out. I knew the Puerto Rican was an excellent pugilist, but I realize now that he is even better than that: a genuine Hall of Fame-caliber fighter.

    • Jimmy Tobin

      Hi Ant,

      You will find no more ardent Cotto supporter than me: he has long been my favourite fighter, and it’s hard to take issue with the guy. Yeah, he’s 1-3 in his biggest fights, but sometimes the means exceed the ends. Cotto is one of those guys–pro’s pro. And there’s no point comparing him to Guerrero, who’s done only enough to get handpicked to take an ass kicking. Shit, Baldomir has a bigger win on his ledger.

      In rewatching Mayweather-Cotto I thought Floyd had an easier time than I did in my, ahem, more lubricated first viewing, but Cotto got to him some, and even this diminished version is a better fighter than Guerrero. I don’t think Floyd is comfortable at 154, which factors into him probably ignoring Canelo for a bit, and it showed in his legs against Cotto. Floyd’s legs looked great last night, and once he decided to use them Guerrero was doomed.

      Not sure if Cotto is a Hall of Fame guy. I’d like to think so, but I’m still learning bout the history of the sport. My historical perspective is nothing to be proud of. I bet Andy and Carlos could give you a well reasoned and informed opinion on Cotto’s HoF credentials.

  • Dennis Wise

    Perfect summation of this affair. I was foolish enough to think Mayweather was going to finish this thing in spectacular fashion after that eight round. I don’t think the bruised hand has anything to do with it. It is simply a matter of what hes trying to accomplish in there. Duplicating round 8 is not it. Once he’s booked a round like that after total domination, he’s going to coast and it doesn’t affect his bottom line. I also agree about his next fight. I don’t think Alvarez can beat him but that’s about all that interests me at this point. I’d love to have seen Martinez a couple years ago against him but at this point I think Martinez has experienced the kind of gradual decline that Pacquiao has. These guys have been fighting guys who are structurally much bigger and even in victory it takes a toll.

    • Jimmy Tobin

      Hi Dennis; thanks.

      The eighth round was impressive. We don’t see that guy often, and sadly, we rarely see him twice in a fight. I don’t know what Mayweather plans on doing in the future (though I doubt very much it involves fighting six times in 30 months) and I don’t really care. He’s on a victory lap, and victory laps don’t get the little hard earned cash I have. Whatever he got from Showtime for the move across the street pretty much guaranteed we’re going to be disappointed with his opponents. He’s beaten damn near everybody, and he’s unquestionably an incredible fighter, but I can’t get excited about his future. Yeah, Alvarez would be great for atmosphere, for the spectacle, but would the fight be any good? Maybe. I’d certainly watch. But I’m not sure Floyd bothers. Why should he when he can win a boring unanimous decision over Devon Alexander for thirty million? Mayweather is further proof we don’t matter as consumers.